curate’s egg
curate’s egg (idiom)
/ˌkjʊərəts ˈɛɡ/
Meaning
- Something that is partly good and partly bad.
- Something that has both good and bad sides.
- Something that is pretty much spoiled, but gets a polite pass because a few bits still look decent.
- A mixed result that leaves you unsure whether to praise it or walk away from it.
Synonyms: mixed bag, mixed blessing, hit and miss, good in parts, double-edged sword.
Example Sentences
- The concert was a curate’s egg — the band sounded great, but the sound system kept cutting out.
- Mike said his new job was a curate’s egg; the pay was better, yet the hours were draining him.
- Sarah called the vacation a curate’s egg after a beautiful first day gave way to rain and a cancelled tour.
- The launch party was a curate’s egg, with good food and awkward speeches sitting side by side.
Etymology and Origin
A Phrase Built on Polite Dishonesty
“Curate’s egg” is what people say when something is good in places and bad in others. At first it meant something worse than that. It pointed to a thing that was spoiled from start to finish, yet spoken of as if a few bits could still be praised. A rotten egg cannot be half excellent. The first laugh came from that polite lie, not from a fair review.
Born in Victorian England
The phrase grew up in late Victorian England. The scene is a junior clergyman sitting down with a bishop. Rank, hospitality, and the fear of giving offence all press on him at once. English humor papers of the 1890s loved that kind of unease, and they gave the joke its first public home.
The Breakfast Joke Before the Phrase
The wording came later than the story. In 1875 a review of the Reverend F. Arnold’s book Our Bishops and Deans, noticed that summer in The Academy, recalled a “young Levite” at a bishop’s breakfast. Offered a fresh egg in place of a bad one, he said, “No thank you, my Lord, it’s good enough for me.” The meek guest and the spoiled egg were already there. What was missing was the claim that parts of the egg were excellent, and the short label that would follow.
Two Cartoons and a Charge of Theft
On 22 May 1895 the London comic paper Judy printed a cartoon by Wilkerson. The bishop says, “Dear me, I’m afraid your egg’s not good!” The timid curate answers, “Oh, yes, my Lord, really – er – some parts of it are very good.” On 9 November that year Punch published George du Maurier’s True Humility. The bishop remarks, “I’m afraid you’ve got a bad egg, Mr. Jones!” The curate replies, “Oh no, my Lord, I assure you! Parts of it are excellent!” Judy later said Punch had taken the gag, and told readers to compare the two issues for themselves. The Punch picture travelled farther, so it is the one most people still remember.
The First Printed Use of the Words
The set phrase itself shows up the next spring. On 19 May 1896 the Edinburgh Evening News, reviewing a play, wrote:
“It is a disappointing play, but that is because it promises so well to begin with. Like the curate’s egg at the Bishop’s breakfast table, it is very good indeed—in parts.”
That is the earliest clear use of the term as a ready comparison. After that, British papers could drop it in without stopping to explain.
From Irony to Mixed Review
The first point was simple. A bad egg is bad all the way through, and calling it good in parts is funny because it is not true. Later speakers kept the picture and let the irony fade. A book with strong chapters and a weak ending, a season with wins and collapses, a stay that began well and then fell apart — all of these became a curate’s egg. The older, sharper sense still appears when a writer wants to hint that the praise is only manners.
What Makes the Story Stick
The phrase lasts because the picture is easy to hold and the social comedy still stings. A junior guest cannot insult a powerful host, so he invents excellence where none exists. When Punch closed its original run in 1992, an artist redrew the scene and had the curate drop the courtesy and swear at the egg. The timid lie that made the idiom famous was, at last, replaced by the plain truth the first cartoon had refused to say.
Variants
- a curate’s egg
- the curate’s egg
- good in parts
Share your opinions